False rape allegations: Why the distorted focus?

Finally – finally! – we get to know just how prevalent false rape accusations have become. As BBC Newsbeat reports “it’s the first time details for England and Wales have been compiled, showing how common the problem is”. From that particular wording, you wouldn’t necessarily think that the answer to that was “not very common at all”. But you’d be wrong. Over the past 17 months there have been two – yes, two – successful prosecutions per month for making false allegations and wasting police time. To put that in perspective, you find an average of 332 prosecutions per month for rape over the same period (something the BBC fails to mention). Even if we set aside the fact that many rapes are not even reported or do not get to trial, it’s quite a contrast. Think of how many times you see stories of false rape allegations reported in the press and imagine if rape convictions were reported in the same way. Every other story you read would be about a rape conviction. But it’s not, is it? Because rape is “the norm” and false allegations are the exception – even if our tendency to focus on the exception means we now think it is the norm (at least if we write for BBC Newsbeat).

Misleading press reporting is only part of the problem, though. As the comments following Keir Starmer’s soberly argued piece in the Guardian show, many people just don’t understand what a false allegation is. Or perhaps they just pretend not to? Either way, withdrawing an allegation of rape is not tantamount to offering proof that the initial claim was a lie. It can be, and frequently is, a response to intense pressure and fear. And while it is possible to argue that if there are more rapes than rape convictions, then there just must be more false allegations than false allegation convictions, this is not as logical as it sounds. A false allegation is, by its very nature, is subject to investigation in a way that an unreported rape never is. Further, while we do see broad cultural trends of rape apologism – from UniLAD to George Galloway to rape jokes on t-shirts – reaching out to the minds of investigators and juries, we’ve never yet seen an equivalent level of sympathy and amusement regarding false rape claims. There’s no UniLADETTE website telling female students that “only two women are prosecuted every month for false rape claims, so the odds on you getting away with it are good” (and to be fair, given what seems to be offered as “evidence” of a woman having lied, I’d say they weren’t such great odds after all).

The very existence of false rape accusation – however rare – seems to present rape apologists with an opportunity to suggest that yes, some men might rape but all’s fair and women give as good as they get. We hear that women are as likely to lie about rape as men are to rape, and that being falsely accused is as bad as being raped (whether or not the latter is the case, our adversarial justice system requires that pretty much all rape victims are falsely accused of being liars, so it’s not as though rape case defendants have a monopoly on false accusation outrage). As far as the likelihood of being falsely accused is concerned, the statistics we have just don’t add up to anything like an equivalence. Furthermore, to suggest that false accusation somehow evens up the balance as far as victimhood is concerned is to live in some bizarre parallel universe in which gender inequality, sexual double standards and the denial of female bodily autonomy do not exist. False rape allegations do not provide some neat way of saying “ha! Women have just as much power to destroy men!” It’s not a game. Nobody is winning here.

If we truly believed that being falsely accused of rape posed a grave threat to all men, perhaps we’d devote a lot of time to telling them how to minimise the risk of being accused (personal freedom be damned!). We’d have lots of fatuous advertising campaigns telling them not to sleep with women and then piss them off (because that, so the story seems to go, is how a false allegation comes about). And yet, we don’t do that. Interestingly, whenever false rape allegations are in the news, the “moral” is always that the woman who lies betrays all real victims of rape. Because we all know that you’re far more likely to be a victim of rape than the victim of a false allegation, just as we know that the onus is always on women to modify their behaviour. As for all the fuss we make of false allegations? It’s just part of the rhetoric of rape culture. It’s not about helping real victims of either crime.


11 thoughts on “False rape allegations: Why the distorted focus?

  1. This post has so many good points I can’t choose which one of them to outline when I share it on Facebook. I will be quoting this often and with gusto whenever the “false accusation” accusations come up. Thank you.

  2. ‘withdrawing an allegation of rape is not tantamount to offering proof that the initial claim was a lie. It can be, and frequently is, a response to intense pressure and fear’

    Yes! Thank you for putting this into words. People talk of women who make rape allegations and then withdraw them because they realise that it wasn’t rape after all. Not because of the way they might be treated after making the allegation – by the alleged rapist, his friends and family, her friends and family, the courts, random dickheads on Twitter, society at large…

    It seems unlikely that many women would make false rape allegations because you don’t exactly win friends with real rape allegations. In the Ched Evans case the Twitter mob kept calling the woman a ‘gold digger’ – when has a woman ever made money from claiming to be raped?!

  3. Really really good post Glosswitch. I love how you show the false equivalence of comparing the number of unreported rapes with women who “get away” with “false” accusations.

  4. Read almost all of the wewebsite visitors have found that the strength of some sort of email marketing system. Moreover, the majority of people have found that that advertising and promotion through social websites will be able to escalate internet site positioning in addition to improve your on the net presence. What precisely almost all of the online surfers are not aware is usually -how they can utilize the strength of social websites within their minor business’s edge. These are some suggestions which may aid you in a person’s email marketing interests. It is important to reflect upon on the subject of email marketing is that you simply are thinking about creating a useful in addition to unique content. It’s a type subject matter exactly who will need to give their particular friends in addition to fans for their social information. Create subject matter that is beneficial in addition to fascinating, usually noone will need to present that. Helpful subject matter http://www.garybirkenmdmedicalmysteries.com/ could generate a person’s eye of one’s supporters in addition to enthusiasts. They should possibly choose to present it all, that could improve your likelihood to get additional fans in addition to potential prospects. Go away place pertaining to research in addition to issues on your social websites promotion, particularly in the beginning. Watch out for what is and what’s no longer working. Evaluation all. Cause modifications simply because crucial. Something valuable pertaining to similar corporations may well not meet your needs. You should learn on a person’s research in addition to problems. When making use of these kinds of internet online selling, you may have to in addition to invigorate a person’s center in addition to goals and objectives frequently. Because of this you might stay with goal. Are present some sort of a number of causes which could bring a person’s advertising and promotion decrease unanticipated tactics. Therefore it is wise to re-evaluate the track it’s going frequently. Do it right often. Look at your campaigns to see the one that is the most good. xrtiu6fd8gf

  5. False rape allegations are not ‘rare’ at all – there fairly common. It’s nothing to do with being a ‘rape appologist’.

    Though i’m sensing some ‘lying bastard appologists’ at work here…

  6. May I know HOW they know how many rape accusations are false?
    There are 3 ways rape accusation can end:
    1. Accused one found guilty.
    2. Accused one found innocent.
    3. Charges dropped.

    False rape accusation can end in any of these 3. So how have they figured out how many false accusations really happens?
    Did they count only these that women came forward and said they accused falsely? If so, such statistic is wrong.

    “If we truly believed that being falsely accused of rape posed a grave threat to all men, perhaps we’d devote a lot of time to telling them how to minimise the risk of being accused ”

    Yes, that posses grave threat to all men. I would rather be accused of murder. Hell I would rather go to jail after being falsely accused of murder than be accused of rape and then go free. Have you heard about men that go free after rape accusation? In eyes of society they ARE rapists, doesn’t matter that they were found innocent. Hell, some of them ends up killed by white knights.

    “we’d devote a lot of time to telling them how to minimise the risk of being accused” I know how to minimize risk of false rape accusation: Don’t be around women without witnesses (also use voice recorder around women ALL THE TIME, and video recorders in your own home), don’t have sex with woman, ALWAYS have alibi for every night (you don’t need to have sex to be falsely accused of rape. What makes it so hard to evade.). In short – stay the hell away from women.

    “And yet, we don’t do that.” Because in this century no one cares about men. It’s the age of disposable tools. And what is more disposable than a man.

    “False rape allegations do not provide some neat way of saying “ha! Women have just as much power to destroy men!” It’s not a game.”
    I am sorry, are you joking? Well pulled off false rape accusation will DESTROY man’s life. Man can do equivalent thing by only crippling woman. Like breaking her spine or something. And he would go jail for that, Woman can destroy man’s life without any risk. Hell, she will even get candy from feminists for doing that and become hero “that fought her oppressor”.

    It’s nice for you to be woman. You have so many privileges. If any man wrote such article that “ah, rape doesn’t happen. It’s so rare that it’s a waste of money and time to try and warn women about rape” (by the way, that 1 in 4 women will be raped is false. Did you knew that? No? Well, then read up. Homework for you.)

Comments are closed.